Working of Law Commission
Introduction of the "Evolution of the Law Commission of India"
The Law Commission of India is a key organization influencing the legal system in the nation. Founded to enact legal reform, it has been instrumental in creating and improving laws to satisfy changing societal demands.
The first Law Commission was established in 1834, during the time of British control, and this is where the Law Commission got its start. However, an executive resolution from the Indian government created the Law Commission of today in 1955. Its original mandate was to make recommendations for legal system improvements.
Key steps in the establishment of the Law Commission of India:
Resolution:
After independence, India needed comprehensive legal reforms, which gave rise to the Law Commission of India concept and the ensuing resolution. After gaining independence in 1947, the young democratic nation was still figuring out how to navigate the challenges of nation-building, and legal changes were seen as essential to ensuring a fair and efficient legal system. An executive resolution from 1955 formalized the decision to create the Law Commission.
Several factors contributed to the genesis of the idea and the formulation of the resolution:
Post-Independence Legal Landscape:
Following independence, it became imperative to examine and revise the colonial-era legal system that was in place. The intricate workings of government and the heterogeneous makeup of Indian society required a thorough evaluation of laws to bring them into compliance with the values of a sovereign state.
Vision for Legal Reform:
Visionary leaders and legal luminaries saw that a legal system that mirrored democratic values and catered to the changing needs of the populace was necessary for an independent India. Legal reform was viewed as a way to guarantee the protection of individual rights, advance justice, and bolster the rule of law.
Expertise and Advisory Body:
Establishing an expert body that could systematically examine legal issues and propose reforms became crucial to this vision. The idea was to create a commission comprising legal experts, jurists, and scholars who could provide valuable insights and recommendations for the enhancement of the legal system.
Alignment with Constitutional Values:
The establishment of the Law Commission aligned with the constitutional values of justice, equality, and the rule of law. It sought to institutionalize a mechanism that would continuously evaluate and improve the legal framework, ensuring its compatibility with the principles enshrined in the Indian Constitution.
Global Legal Practices:
Global legal practices also influenced the idea of a Law Commission. Many countries had similar bodies in place to review and recommend legal reforms. Drawing from these international models, the framers of the resolution sought to adopt best practices for legal governance.
The culmination of these factors led to the formulation of the resolution for the establishment of the Law Commission of India in 1955. The resolution, approved by the government, defined the composition, functions, and mandate of the commission. It marked a significant step toward creating a dynamic and expert body that would play a pivotal role in shaping the legal landscape of the nation.
In essence, the idea behind the resolution was rooted in the vision of creating a legal institution that would not only respond to immediate post-independence challenges but would also serve as a perpetual mechanism for legal evolution in the years to come.
Composition and Appointment:
The resolution delineated the composition of the commission, specifying the appointment of a chairman and other members. Traditionally, the chairman hails from the ranks of retired Supreme Court judges in India, while the commission comprises legal luminaries, jurists, and scholars renowned in their respective fields. Its composition typically includes:
Chairman:
The Chairman of the Law Commission is usually a distinguished legal expert, often a retired judge of the Supreme Court or a legal luminary with significant experience in the field.
The Chairman leads the commission’s activities and plays a crucial role in shaping its recommendations.
Members:
The commission comprises legal experts, jurists, academicians, and professionals with diverse legal backgrounds.
The number of members may fluctuate, with their appointments strategically tailored to ensure a diverse array of legal expertise, thus enriching the breadth and depth of the commission’s collective knowledge.
Appointment Process:
The appointment process for the Law Commission involves a series of steps:
Nomination and Consultation:
Prospective candidates are frequently nominated or endorsed based on their exceptional legal prowess, specialized knowledge, and significant contributions to the legal realm, aligning with the overarching objectives of the Law Commission of India.
The Central Government may consult with the Chief Justice of India and other legal luminaries during selection.
Government Approval:
Once nominations are received, the Central Government reviews the recommendations and makes the final decision on the appointment of the Chairman and members.
Terms and Conditions:
The terms and conditions of service, including the tenure of the Chairman and members, are specified at the time of appointment.
The appointments are typically made with due consideration to maintaining the independence and integrity of the Law Commission of India.
Functional Autonomy:
The Law Commission operates independently, free from external influences, to carry out its functions effectively.
The autonomy of the commission is essential to ensure unbiased and impartial recommendations.
Reappointment:
In some cases, members may be eligible for reappointment, allowing experienced individuals to continue contributing to the commission’s work over multiple terms.
Through its composition and appointment mechanisms, the Law Commission of India endeavours to assemble a diverse array of legal luminaries, fostering an environment where varied perspectives converge to tackle contemporary legal complexities and advocate for reforms that uphold the principles of justice and the rule of law.
Functions and Mandate:
The Law Commission of India is bestowed with a myriad of responsibilities and mandates, chiefly centred on conducting legal research, spearheading reforms, and enhancing the efficacy of the legal system to better serve the needs of society.
Here are the key functions and mandates of the Law Commission:
Legal Reforms:
The primary function of the Law Commission is to examine and review existing laws in India.
It recommends reforms and suggests amendments to outdated or inadequate laws to keep the legal system in tune with societal needs and developments.
Research and Studies:
The commission conducts in-depth research on legal issues, emerging trends, and areas requiring attention.
It undertakes comprehensive studies to understand the implications of proposed legal changes and provides well-reasoned reports.
Consultation:
The Law Commission often consults with legal experts, stakeholders, and the public to gather diverse perspectives before formulating recommendations.
To ensure a comprehensive grasp of legal issues, the Law Commission of India may orchestrate seminars, facilitate discussions, or solicit feedback through public consultations, thereby fostering an inclusive and participatory approach to legal discourse and decision-making.
Drafting Legislation:
One of the crucial mandates is the preparation of draft legislation to implement recommended reforms.
The commission holds the authority to draft bills and propose statutory amendments aimed at rectifying gaps or inadequacies within prevailing laws, thereby contributing to the ongoing evolution and refinement of the legal framework.
Advisory Role:
The commission serves in an advisory capacity to the government on legal matters.
It provides expert opinions and advice on legal issues referred to it by the government or upon its initiative.
Examine Specific Issues:
The Law Commission may be tasked with examining specific legal issues or questions referred to it by the government, judiciary, or other authorities.
It investigates and provides comprehensive reports with recommendations on these issues.
Review International Legal Practices:
The commission may study and analyze legal practices and reforms in other jurisdictions to incorporate international best practices in Indian law.
Promote Legal Education:
The commission may take initiatives to promote legal education and awareness, contributing to the overall development of the legal profession and justice system.
Periodic Reports:
The Law Commission periodically submits reports to the government, summarizing its findings, recommendations, and the progress of legal reforms. In essence, the Law Commission of India assumes a pivotal role in moulding and enhancing the legal terrain, guaranteeing that law remains pertinent, equitable, and attuned to the dynamic requirements of society’s evolution.
Continuity and Reconstitution:
The Law Commission is typically reconstituted every three years with new members. This ensures a continuous and dynamic approach to legal reform, allowing the commission to adapt to changing circumstances.
Legal Framework:
The establishment and operation of the Law Commission are substantiated by a multitude of statutes and acts, thereby providing legal legitimacy to its mandate and functions within the Indian legal framework. The resolution aligns with the constitutional framework, enabling the commission to operate within the legal parameters set by the Indian Constitution.
The Law Commission of India, since its inception, has been instrumental in providing valuable recommendations for legal reforms, contributing to the evolution of the Indian legal system.
Landmark Reports and Recommendations:
The Law Commission has generated a collection of influential reports and recommendations that have left a lasting imprint on legal progressions in India. Prominent among these reports are those pertaining to criminal law reforms, family law, and electoral reforms. These seminal documents have offered invaluable insights and suggestions for legislative enhancements, shaping the course of legal evolution in the country.
Here are some notable reports and recommendations:
174th Report on Electoral Reforms (1999):
This report addressed issues related to the electoral system, disqualification of candidates, and criminalization in politics. It suggested various reforms to enhance the electoral process.
195th Report on Death Penalty (2006):
Examining the death penalty in India, this report recommended the abolition of the death penalty for all crimes except terrorism-related offenses and waging war.
198th Report on Prevention of Torture (2008):
Focusing on the prevention of torture, this report recommended the ratification of the UN Convention against Torture, along with domestic legislation to criminalize torture.
226th Report on Manpower Planning in Judiciary (2009):
Addressing the issue of judicial vacancies and delays, this report proposed measures for effective manpower planning to improve the efficiency of the judiciary.
245th Report on Legal Education – Professional Autonomy and Accountability (2014):
This report emphasized the need for reforms in legal education, including balancing professional autonomy and accountability of legal institutions.
246th Report on Review of Rape Laws (2013).
Controversies and Criticisms:
Similar to any institution, the Law Commission has encountered its fair share of controversies and criticisms. Debates over the implementation of its recommendations, delays in legislative action, and occasional disagreements on certain issues have sparked discussions about the commission’s efficacy.
Recent Developments:
In recent years, the Law Commission has continued its work in various legal domains. Its endeavours to streamline and simplify laws, along with a steadfast commitment to social justice, underscore its enduring significance in shaping India’s legal framework.
Conclusion:
The Law Commission of India stands as a pivotal institution committed to perpetually improving the legal framework within the country. Through its rigorous scrutiny of prevailing laws, extensive research endeavors, and visionary recommendations, the commission assumes a central role in steering the trajectory of legal reforms. The landmark reports and recommendations produced by the commission underscore its commitment to addressing contemporary legal challenges and ensuring that the legal system evolves in tandem with societal needs. As the commission continues to adapt and respond to emerging issues, its contributions remain essential in fostering a just, equitable, and dynamic legal landscape in India.
The Uniform Civil Code represents a proposition in India aimed at crafting and enforcing personal laws that are applicable to all citizens uniformly, irrespective of their religion, gender, or sexual orientation.
Justice Ritu Raj Awasthi
About the Author
Your point of view caught my eye and was very interesting. Thanks. I have a question for you.